Welcome to BlackandBrownNews.com! Your News, Information and Community Network Connecting You To The World.

(Image of the Day) 'Jail Playground’ at NYC Public Housing Property.

March 21, 2010 by BBN Editors,

Jail_Thompkins.jpg

Photograph courtesy of Photographer and Brooklyn resident, Monifa Bandele

UPDATE (3.23.10): BBN visited the property at Tompkins Houses in Bedford Stuyvesant where the jungle gym stands and found that the structure is manufactured with “Jail” and the cell door. The lettering and cell door is not painted on the structure. For clarification of which city agency orders these products, BBN contacted the local representative of the manufacturer who explained that New York City Housing Authority orders these structures and that the city agency selects the items.

BBN contacted NYCHA and spoke with spokesperson, Sheila Stainback, who would only say, “We are looking into it and assessing the situation and what needs to be done.” Ms. Stainback also said she would get back to us about when the structure would be removed and replaced. As of the filing of this update NYCHA has not contacted us with a response.

BBN contacted Mayor Bloomberg’s Press Office and was told by the person who answered the telephone that someone would get back to us. As of the filingof this update the Mayor’s Press Office has not responded to us.

While visiting the property yesterday, BBN spoke with a Tompkins Houses resident, Maria (she did not give us her last name), who was walking with her five year old son about the jungle gym with “Jail” written on it. “I don’t think they should put that there in a neighborhood where many Blacks and Latinos go to jail. My son will ask me, Mommy, if I go in there, will I go to jail,” Maria said.

BBN is waiting for responses from the NYCHA and the Mayor’s Office. Among several other questions, we will ask city officials if other NYCHA properties have this same jungle gym structure on playgrounds, and who is responsible for selecting and ordering products for playgrounds.

BBN will keep you posted.

Original Story (3.21.10) There is no kind, gentle, diplomatic way to describe the offense against a community by this ‘Jail Playground’ on a New York City Housing Authority property, located at Tompkins Houses (Park Avenue between Tompkins and Throop) in Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn, where Black and Latino children live and play. (Disproportionately, Black and Latinos enter the criminal justice system. Encouraging young Black and Latino children to first play in Jail until they may actually get to jail or prison is playing loosey-goosey with their young, impressionable psyche and something no community should stand for or be subjected to).

Mr. Mayor Bloomberg, whether or not the word “Jail” was painted on after the City erected the apparatus or it came manufactured with “Jail” written on it, this egregious offense still falls on the City to take corrective action immediately.

Because of the nature of the offense we ask that the City of New York respond with the same urgency and expediency it would for residents - including children - who live and play in city owned-operated parks on the Upper West Side (below Washington Heights), the Upper Eastside (below Harlem), Battery Park City and definitely Brooklyn Heights and Park Slope – both in Brooklyn. We ask that the City disassemble and replace the ‘Jail Playground’ with suitable, appropriate, safe (body and mind) recreational apparatus within 24 hours (no need to drag the feet of bureaucracy on this one).

We encourage the City to review all recreational apparatus on city owned-operated housing developments and parks in neighborhoods where these offenses are more likely to occur. And, we encourage residents in and around Tompkins Houses to contact the Mayor’s Office, New York City Housing Authority and the Community Board representing the area.

BBN can’t thank enough photographer Monifa Bandele for being observant, taking the photograph and permitting us to post it.

City of New York Government Numbers

-- Mayor’s Office 212.788.3000 (may route you to 3-1-1)
-- NYC Housing Authority 212.306.3000

report with friends





momof2
I guess you never played jail as a kid? I sure did. I think you're finding offense where none needs to exist. Just as violent video games do not lead to real-life violence, playing jail does not lead to jail time. We had a playhouse that my sisters put a baby gate in and that was our jail. Ever read Roxaboxen? The kids had a jail for the town they made. I do wish it wasn't labeled "jail", just 'cause I'm sure would want to use the space for other types of enclosures, but really? This is not that big a deal.


kirbyny
a lot of people played jail, cops and robbers, cowboys and Indians, but we didn't live that experience. whoever doesn't think jail on a playground jungle gym at a public housing playground is not such a big deal God bless them and I want to live in their world. i want to know who in the city government thought this was okay. will bbn follow up?


sethruffer
I respectfully disagree with momof2. Ours is a society that imprisons too many of its own members, disproportionately minorities. For the city government, which has the power to imprison, to authorize putting this is a children's playground is nauseating. This is not some kids playing, or a book bought with personal funds/discretion. This is the city of NY sending a message to children that one of the places they encounter in their daily life is jail. Disgusting. As a Jew I first thought it was the equivalent of a swastika being put up in a Jewish Center playground, but it's worse than that. This wasn't placed by some sociopathic thugs--it was put there by the City of New York. It makes me sick, and I also want to know two things: why has the mainstream media ignored this? If this had happened in Scarsdale, would MSM have ignored it?


missprofe
@momof2 If you believe it's ok for children to play under such conditions, then you have no soul. The situation is reprehensible.


LeeCee76623
They might as well have made a miniature plantation, slave quarters and a graveyard while they were at it! How insulting...look kiddies this is where your going when you grow up so let's all practice now!!! Wow this really makes me angry!


Mina007
Unfortunately we are still facing fierce racial times. Individuals who share Momof2's viewpoint are scary to me, because they are not privy to the real mission and aim of "The powers that be", and I'm not talking about our beloved President right now. The agenda was set hubdreds of years ago. Wake up, children. When we played "jail" 40 years ago, our people were in better shape. Now, they're programming has been successful and those who are still sleeping will get slaughtered first. Just like the sweet little sheep who moves with the herd. It's real, live and direct. Pay attention and take heed. De-program yourself and you'll see the mayhem. Stay Blessed* One*




Mina007
Individuals who share Momof2's viewpoint are scary to me, because they are not privy to the real mission and aim of "The powers that be", and I'm not talking about our beloved President right now. The agenda was set hundreds of years ago. Wake up, children. When we played "jail" 40 years ago, our people were in better shape. Now, they're programming has been successful and those who are still sleeping will get slaughtered first. Just like the sweet little sheep who moves with the herd. It's real, live and direct. Pay attention and take heed. De-program yourself and you'll see the mayhem. Stay Blessed* One*


bradwatching
Oh boy, where does one begin with this one. The "fierce racial times" are fueled by people just as yourselves by even calling this the "Black and Brown News", what about the Honkey's, Chinks & Redskins? Why are they not represented? Are the readers of this article that poorly educated? (I bet they played on a playground that might have looked like a schoolhouse) If a child see's a jail playground that means they will be in jail? Why not use it as a learning experience to discuss how to conduct yourself as a human so you do not end up in jail? I bet if the city put a hospital playground in, then someone would find it offensive because that's where only Black and Brown people go after they have been stabbed or shot instead of becoming a nurse or doctor. Time to let kids play and parents take responsiblity for the proper social development of their off spring....... oh they're in jail because they must have played on a playgound that looked like a one. Wake up!!! take some of this energy and focus on the real issues that effect our community


Funloving
Looks like fun, my brothers used to play cops and robbers as kids i would play sometimes...I wish we had such nice looking park monkey bars...I don’t know of anyone from university houses that went to jail? I think this is a joke and the person who wrote this should hang there head in shame, you are a poor role model. Forget about a non issue, why don’t you contact Kayne West and have him build you a beautiful playground like this one, leave the Jail item off get the kids out and play and most of all try becoming an adult’s not an whiney babies. Wake up, and stop complaining ! And to the dope comparing this item to a swastika , your not a dope you’re a moron… See you in central park


choge1
What a travesty that in this day and age the people live in the Tompkins Houses seem to be sleepwalking! They should have withheld their rents before allowing their children to be subjected to such an indignity! Thanks for the people who realized the damage already done and aided in the remedy for such sublimation.


mikamousie
The biggest shame here is that it took residents/a passerby this long to complain about this obviously tasteless move by the city. I wonder how many other NYC communities have playgrounds that contain such offensive structures. We must start demanding better for our children.


ENY4eva
Speechless!


smoore
The signs are all around.


LadyinRed
Ok...as a kid many of us played Cowboys and Indians, Cops and Robbers, etc. Our parents allowed these games because they, AND we, understood that they were just games. The majority of us who played these games certainly didn't wind up in jail. I agree that the sign was in poor taste and if anything, people are guilty of being thoughtless or unobservant. However, if as reported that complaints were made, why wasn't these complaint brought to the attention of the powers that be downtown; they stayed within the development. While I suspect there's some apathy at play here, it could ALSO be that the complaint wasn't taken seriously. And,one more thing...for those parents who say it is in poor taste and racist, I wonder how many of them purchase those violent video games that their children play, and they don't complain about those. We can't have it both ways people; pick a position and stick to it! If you complain about the JAIL playground and stick racism into the picture, you should be doing the same with those video games!


alilamos
It's not surprising that people that use the park haven't complained, just as its not surprising that educated people commenting here don't see a problem with this. We are taught to ignore these signs throughout our lives. People do not reach consciousness without effort, whether rich or poor. We all receive the same messages. this is quite different from children imagining various play themes on their own. In order to understand the meaning of a city-created playground using a jail motif in an area of poverty and high youth incarceration, while playgrounds in higher-income areas do not have this theme, you would need to have an understanding of the historical, social, economic, and psychological context of structural racism in America. This takes growing up in a conscious environment or seeking to elevate your own consciousness through self-education on how structural racism has impacted our own thinking and impacted the social structure of our society I'm glad the city is being called out on this and I'm sad that so many people lack the empathy to understand how this compounds the many negative messages to children growing up in Bed Stuy. Even in the playground they aren't safe from these messages.


CarefulCItizen
momof2 is exactly right. After 6 years, only 1 complaint about this playground? Where was black&brown for those 6 years? It's this mentality of victimization that keeps people in their place. How about an attitude of empowerment instead? For heaven's sake, we all played cowboys & indians, cops & robbers as kids. I was given toy guns by adults for these games. Did I accuse them of instilling violence and oppression in a young mind? It's ridiculous!


Mr.+Richmon
This story was outrageous. I read about it in a news article this morning. It mentioned this site as the initial source so i joined A.S.A.P. Too long do our communities continue to put up with blatant disrespect and disregard for our residents. Our complaints go unheard or ridiculed or sited as we are overreacting, or oversensitive or reading into things that are not there. We all know any other race will fight back, sue, make heads roll, demand a public apology, etc. How did we get so far away from the civil rights movement? answer.


tj
orange spray paint in the wee hours of the morning real stealthily will clean that right up. that's a long wait to get that sign taken down.


vzboy
I heard this story on Opie and Anthony, can't believe you morons are making a big deal about this. Has none of you played cops and robbers ? It's part of kids being kids, what's next, not letting them play cowboys and indians ? You should be glad that there is a playground at all. This a non story, could you be mad because you can't stand the truth ? If you parents payed some attention to your kids, then maybe they would be headed down the right path !


Alsharp68
You stupid niggers need to focus on things other than trying to blame your problems on "the man" or Whitey. Black man is in the white house people, stop acting like niggers are being hung from trees like the good ole days. Maybe get a job and afford to rent or buy a house of your very own. It's a really good feeling people... look at me, I ride you dirty stupid niggers and I ride in limos and wear thousand dollar suites.


truthseeker
the problem here is that we have brought into the system of mental degradation and noncritical thinking one of the greatest crime that we in the black community have committed is failure to protect and perserve and promote a positive image in our children. We cannot expect the enemy of our existence to be kind, nurture and develop our families , particularly our children. i lived in another part of bklyn, come over the playground near prospect park and second start and the one at pros pk and 9th street, see if you see and equipment which says jail on it. did anyone ever complain to their elective official and did anyone ever bring a civil rights claims against the NYCHA discrimination in treatment of residents as compared to lets say Sheepshead Bay Housing- wake up life is not a game, get involved and protect our children


the_dude
It's been there for 6 years? get a can of paint and cover it up. Any attempt by law enforcement to stop you or to prosecute you will only bring this more publicity, and you have clearly waited long enough to get this fixed.


chimpincharge
Dem chilluns jus bees in tranins fo da fuucher. Yaws nos wuts i meens! Dem dam crackas bees rasis n sheeit. dis is a owtradge!


jlgarwood
I vote they paint over it and put the words CEO Office. Why not? Let kids play with bigger dreams! I hope a few people get fired over this and let them play on a jungle gym with a door that says Unemployment Office.


Rashad
Why didn't the community! cover up those signs!?.....how long! as that been that way?....Wow!...I think the damage! has already been done! to the kids that knew what it was.....some one should have written...President! over that!.... I blame the parents! for letting there kids play! on that....Wow! is all I can really say.....


Rashad
Every one please ignore....."ALSHARP68"....thats probally a self hating!..."Black" person...and whoever he or she or it! is....give that thing! no feed back .... Stay Strong! Family.....


chimpincharge
Would they not be more offended by being placed in a "jungle gym"? At least they are getting a free ride from the taxpayers.


kirbyny
Jlgarwood, Now that's a really Good one!


chimpincharge
What is next on the long list of things to be offend by in the AA community...snow, per chance? If someone is looking to be offend, they will most certainly find something.


chimpincharge
The niglets ought to feel right at home by the time that they are teenapers, after playing on those "monkey bars"!


saintlysecret
Watch out for those Monopoly boards too! Being insulted about this is just another aspect of urban black pathology. This neighborhood is a huge source of criminals. Why? Ask yourselves. WHY???? But instead of hearing an answer to that question, we see punishment of innocent makers of play equipment for happening to expose the ugliness of the punisher. INSTEAD, CLEAN UP THE NEIGHBORHOOD. Then you will have nothing to be ashamed of.


crownhghtsma
The very idea that this play jail existed in this community is very telling. The idea that a mom of any color would condone it and call it inoffensive is worrisome to say the least. I am stunned that it stayed unspoken of for such a long time. Shame on the parents who allowed their children who already feel that jail is actually an option for not causing the biggest stink ever. Shame on the politicians who never noticed, looking at any assemblyman, or local politician who hadn't canvassed that park. Shame on the designer who didn't question the idiocy of that inclusion, and suggest an option. Shame on all of the trouble makers who are pointing fingers and hurling epithets. It's telling and scary. I heard of this blog from the Daily News stories. I find no offence in the name of the blog, but then others do, yet don't worry about black kids getting use to being in jail before they attend school. A topsy turvy world we live in.


Luckytobeme
This is totally unacceptable. Strength are in numbers and the residents of Tompkins Projects should rally together and contact their local congressman, while also getting a lawyer and filing a case against NYCHA immediately. I bet when this is done we will see how quickly those four letters are removed. I wonder how this would play out if they put the words Concentration Camp in the play area of one of the NYCHA buildings in Williamsburg? Hmmm......


chimpincharge
This "jungle gym" could use some more "monkey bars"! It also would be nice to plant some cottonwood trees in this asphalt jungle and have them decorated with nooses with thirteen winds each, and have each rope lubricated with forrest lard! As I have said before, the ghetto lobsters, niglets and yard apes are just in training for their futures! Later, You Kike loving, blue gummed porch monkeys!


HNIC
whats the big deal? hits too close to home huh?


HNIC
be glad u have a playground! my kids dont!



HNIC
everything is racist. waah! quit commiting crimes, get up off your lazy asses and do something other than complaining about whitey and you might go somewhere.getting sick of it! enough already!dammm


bonobo
Haha. Maybe the Latinos and niggers go to jail "disproportionately" because they are MORE LIKELY TO COMMIT CRIMES. Haha stupid niggers can't find nothing better to do than bitch about kids playing cops and robbers. Fuck you left wingers. Go getcha sum o' dat brown shuguh! But you stay away from our Aryan ladies or your butts are mine! SIEG HEIL!!! YEE-HAWW!!!! WHITE REVOLUTION IS THE ONLY FUCKING SOLUTION, GOTTA PUT AN END TO THIS ALIEN INTRUSION!!!


hclark
Bonobo -- You are a complete asshole. And assuming that you are white, I am ashamed to be the same color as you. By the way, I am redneck, white and republican. But you are still an asshole.


hclark
On the other hand, I am offended by the earlier post's use of the word "disproportionate". Perhaps it is not that minorities are "disproportionately" CONVICTED of crimes that is important to note. Maybe it is the reality that a "disproportionate" number of these crimes ARE COMMITTED by minorities that should be noted and corrected. Prison populations are something like 90% minority. Maybe stop committing the crimes and the use of words like "disproportionate" would be unnecessary.




Wotanskriger
Fuck you niggers. Fuck you Mr. hclarck. Get the fuck out of Dixie. DIE NIGGERS SIEG HEIL!


wotanskriger
Haha. Maybe the Latinos and niggers go to jail "disproportionately" because they are MORE LIKELY TO COMMIT CRIMES. Haha stupid niggers can't find nothing better to do than bitch about kids playing cops and robbers. Fuck you left wingers. Go getcha sum o' dat brown shuguh! But you stay away from our Aryan ladies or your butts are mine! SIEG HEIL!!! YEE-HAWW!!!! WHITE REVOLUTION IS THE ONLY FUCKING SOLUTION, GOTTA PUT AN END TO THIS ALIEN INTRUSION!!!


NTheLoopOrg+Inc
I am sickened at some of the responses of the playgrounds psychological impact of the unconsciousness message to such a vulnerable mind of a child that this visual tool implies. You can not be serious to think that there is much more to worry about than the proper development of a child’s mind, thoughts, and imagination of themselves. If you pick and choose importance nothing is. It is amazing that out of all the developments that could have been created they picked a jail with no precinct…hmmmm? What about a hospital, school, firehouse, store even; a jail where they are programming the child to either get ready to be there or put someone in your community there, which one, maybe you’ll find some importance in that decision. Where are the people of color today (mind-set)? Why are we the people of color today (hopeless)? And who are the people of color today (culture-social awareness)? It’s as simple as A, B, C’s and 1, 2, 3’s the basics of education…Get involved. NTheLoop Org Inc.


CDog
I think this matter is escalating way out of proportion. We have established that whoever was involved in the decision to apply the words jail was wrong to have done that. It is also clear that had they approached the public about the plans before hand, they would have soon realised this would be a bad decision. Now that the public have had their say then the city have a chance to correct their actions. I imagine the decision to include a jail was not one with an ulterior motive and so there is no reason to get so heated over it. The city should change this immediately to suffice the community dislike.


CDog
On another note this playground does not do much justice to the area, there should be allot more brighter colours to inspire the childrens minds. Racist comments are completely unnecessary! What are you lot back in the 1800's???



Add a Comment

Join BBN for free to post a comment on this page.
If you already have an account, please login here to post a comment on this page.

20 Most Recent Stories